George Steinbrenner Yankees

Shortly before the Texas Rangers game on Wednesday, July 28th, this was tweeted out by Rangers’ Director of Communications John Blake:

Long rumored to be a trade candidate, it finally looked like former first round draft pick Joey Gallo was on the move. Would the Rangers be getting C.J. Abrams from the Padres, or maybe Robert Hassell Jr.??? Would it be the Yankees, who had been rumored to be seeking a power-hitting lefty for their lineup? Or was there some Dark Horse team, maybe the Braves(!), who were swooping in at the last moment?

Alas, my worst fears were confirm: Joey Gallo would be playing in pinstripes. And worse, perhaps, was the fact that he’s have to trim his mighty beard.

Yankees Farm Club

Like Billy Beane in Moneyball, Rangers fans have often been heard saying “we’re just a farm club for the Yankees” or “he’ll look good in pinstripes one day.” This is because everyone knows that the Yankees don’t actually develop their teams, they buy them or trade for them. “Fuck drafting! What’re we, the Oakland A’s! Let’s just make other players…our players!”

Need proof? Let’s take a look at the 26-man roster on August 31, 2021 and see how many players actually made their Major League debuts with the team:

Pitchers Debuted with the Yankees? How’d he become a Yankee?
Aroldis Chapman 54 No Free Agency
Gerrit Cole 45 No Free Agency
Néstor Cortes Jr. 65 No Free Agency
Chad Green 57 Yes! Trade with Tigers
Andrew Heaney 38 No Trade with Angels
Clay Holmes 35 No Trade with Pirates
Corey Kluber 28 No Free Agency
Jonathan Loáisiga 43 Yes! Minor League FA
Lucas Luetge 63 No Free Agency
Jordan Montgomery 47 Yes! DRAFTED BY YANKEES!!!
Wandy Peralta 58 No Trade with Giants
Joely Rodríguez 30 No Trade with Rangers
Jameson Taillon 50 No Trade with Pirates
Kyle Higashioka 66 Yes! DRAFTED BY YANKEES!!!
Gary Sánchez 24 Yes! J2 SIGNING!
DJ LeMahieu 26 No Free Agency
Rougned Odor 12 No Trade with Rangers
Anthony Rizzo 48 No Trade with Cubs
Gio Urshela 29 No Free Agency?
Andrew Velazquez 71 No Free Agency
Luke Voit 59 No Trade with Cardinals
Tyler Wade 14 Yes! DRAFTED BY YANKEES!!!
Joey Gallo 13 No Trade with Rangers
Brett Gardner 11 Yes! DRAFTED BY YANKEES!!!
Aaron Judge 99 Yes! DRAFTED BY YANKEES!!!
Designated Hitter
Giancarlo Stanton 27 No Trade with Marlins

Clearly, the Yankees don’t do a lot of “developing from within.” So what happens when a player becomes a Yankee through Free Agency, Trade, or some other baseball Dark Arts? Aside from giving up their soul to play for the Evil Empire, players must make another sacrifice:

They must cut their hair.

Flow Reduction

Since 1972, the New York Yankees have had a policy that prohibits players, coaches, and male executives from having flow. Having salad! Having a kick-ass signature “look.” Here’s the official language of the policy:

“All players, coaches and male executives are forbidden to display any facial hair other than mustaches (except for religious reasons), and scalp hair may not be grown below the collar. Long sideburns and ‘mutton chops’ are not specifically banned.”

Pretty archaic, huh?

If a player becomes a Yankee, gone are the days of personal expression via Tremendous Flow. Say goodbye to Kentucky Waterfalls, Vanilla Gorillas, Mississippi Mud Flaps, Camaro Crash Helmets, and anything resembling a beard. Nope. You’re a Yankee now, son.

With the reduction in follicles comes a reduction in swag, and we at Nerd Nexus lament for dudes who have to get “cleaned up” for their jobs. Today, we look at the most dramatic and tragic reduction in V I B E S that have been endured by MLB players that became Yankees. We’ll start with the newest Yankee, former Ranger Great…

Joey Gallo

Texas Rangers NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Joey Gallo

Joey Gallo was drafted by the Texas Rangers in the first round of the 2012 and made his MLB debut in 2015. All he did was go 3-4 with a homer in his first game. Since then, Gallo has become one of the most feared power hitters (and right fielders) in all of baseball. Chicks dig the long ball, and they also dig Joey – he was an absolute stud for the Rangers and, with his glowing smile and regular moonshots, regularly led the Rangers in both homers and jerseys sold.

Then, he was traded to the Yankees and made to shave. In true Samson fashion, Joey is slashing .149/.312/.356 (he was at .223/.379/.490 with TEX) since the trade and he also looks like a disappointed 8th grader.

Still love you, Joey! #BringJoeyBack2023

Rougned Odor

Texas Rangers NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Rougned Odor

Ahhhhh Rougie. What a tale to tell our children.

The Rangers felt so good about minor league prospect Rougned Odor that they drafted perennial All-Star Ian Kinsler to Detroit for perennial All-Star Prince Fielder (RIP Prince) and installed Rougie as their everyday second baseman. He rewarded the Rangers and their fans with 146 home runs in 7 season, questionable defense, swagger by the boatloads, and one dazed & confused Jose Bautista.

But, as we learned in Blade Runner, the candle that burns twice as bright burns half as long, and Rougie burned so bright that the Rangers kinda got tired of him and traded him to the Yankees before the 2021 season. Odor subsequently shaved his signature facial hair and we were all reminded that he’s still only 27 years old.

Gerrit Cole

Pittsburgh Pirates NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Cutch Gerrit Cole

Gerrit Cole was the first overall pick by the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2011 out of UCLA, and honestly, I kinda give Cole a pass for electing to sign with the Yankees when he reached Free Agency because

  1. They gave him a 9-year/$324 million dollar contract
  2. He is a proven Yankees fan for life.

He still looks only half as badass as a Yankee though, and also, he seems to have lost a bit of his edge.

Johnny Damon

Boston Red Sox NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Johnny Damon

Johnny Freakin’ Damon, man.

He was baseball Jesus! He was a light-throwing, slap-hitting, Billy Ray Cyrus-looking everyman who helped Boston to their first World Series title in like a million years! Then, he joined the Dark Side, signed with the Yankees, shaved his beard, and then this happened.

Coincidence? Doubt it.

Andrew McCutcheon

Pittsburgh Pirates NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Cutch Andrew McCutchen

Was there a player more badass than Cutch in the early 00’s? He helped Pittsburgh make it to the playoffs for the first time in nearly thirty years as he ripped the ball around PNC Park with kick-ass dreads in tow. He had it all: the chain, the hair, the goatee, all 5 Tools, and an NL MVP Award.

After being traded from Pittsburgh to San Francisco, the Yankees hoped he could regain some of his 2014 magic and acquired him from the Giants in 2014. In Cutch’s 2 months as a Yankee, he hit .253 with an .892 OPS, but there’s no tellin’ what he would’ve done had he not had to cut his signature dreadlocks – dude looked like Cedric Daniels from The Wire.

Nick Swisher

Nick Swisher NYY Yankees NYC Yankees Oakland A's

Nick Swisher went from beer-chugging broski “Swish” to “Mr. Swisher, Esquire” real quick, huh?

Taking A Stand

The Yankees facial hair policy is obviously rooted in the past; American workplaces just don’t operate like this anymore, and people quit over much pettier things than facial hair. Are the Yankees in danger of losing clout with players? Perhaps, but others might argue that if you’re getting paid multiple millions of dollars to play a game, no matter how skilled you are, you ought to shut your mouth, cut your hair, and get to work.

I say fuck all that though, just like current Dodgers pitcher David Price did:

“I wouldn’t sign a long-term deal (with the Yankees). Those rules, that’s old-school baseball. I was born in ’85. That’s not for me. That’s not something I want to be a part of.”

Well said, David. You keep rockin’ in the free world, where you can grow whatever kind of hair you want.

Stay tuned to and as always, follow Nerd Nexus on Instagram at @Nerd.Nexus and on Twitter at @NerdNexus and stay tuned for more nerdy news, features, and podcasts.

Editor-in-Chief & Founder of

1 thought on “The Greatest Casualties Of The Yankees’ Facial Hair Policy

Leave a Reply